The story of Christmas, celebrated worldwide as the birth of Jesus Christ, carries profound themes of hope, resilience, and inclusion. It is also a narrative deeply rooted in the experiences of migration and displacement. Mary and Joseph, as key figures in the Nativity story, faced daunting obstacles, including a government-ordered journey and the inability to find shelter. Their experience resonates with the struggles of countless migrants throughout history, including those impacted by restrictive policies in modern times. In a profound irony, it seems unlikely there would be room for Jesus in a country run by christian nationalists.

If America is for Americans only, then a middle eastern Jew name Jesus has no place here.

The Nativity as a Tale of Migration

The journey to Bethlehem, as recounted in the Gospel of Luke, begins with a government mandate. Emperor Augustus issued a decree requiring all citizens to register for a census, compelling Mary and Joseph to leave their home in Nazareth and travel to Bethlehem. Mary, pregnant and near term, undertook this arduous journey under circumstances of duress—a journey mirrored in the lives of refugees fleeing war, famine, or persecution in search of safety and stability.

Upon reaching Bethlehem, Mary and Joseph faced rejection and exclusion, as “there was no room in the inn.” This moment highlights the vulnerability of migrants who, despite their urgent need for shelter, are often met with indifference or hostility. Jesus, born in a stable among animals, entered the world as a figure of humility, solidarity, and resilience—qualities that resonate with the experiences of those forced to navigate the margins of society.

The narrative does not end there. After Jesus’ birth, King Herod’s violent decree to kill all male children under two years old forced the Holy Family to flee to Egypt. This act of political persecution transformed them into refugees, seeking asylum in a foreign land to escape violence. Their flight to Egypt mirrors the modern plight of asylum seekers fleeing oppressive regimes, seeking sanctuary in countries where they hope for safety and a chance to rebuild their lives.

Immigration Policies in the Trump Era

Fast forward to contemporary times, and the themes of the Nativity story take on new significance in the context of modern immigration policy. Under Donald Trump’s administration, a series of restrictive measures profoundly impacted migrants and refugees. The “zero-tolerance” policy led to the separation of thousands of families at the U.S.-Mexico border, creating a humanitarian crisis that drew widespread condemnation. The travel ban targeting predominantly Muslim-majority countries further restricted the movement of vulnerable populations, including refugees fleeing conflict zones.

These policies often invoked the language of national security and economic preservation, yet they also revealed a troubling lack of empathy for the human stories behind migration. The separation of families echoes the rejection and vulnerability faced by Mary and Joseph when seeking shelter. Refugees turned away from borders evoke the plight of the Holy Family fleeing Herod’s tyranny.

The Trump administration’s policies also stand in stark contrast to the central message of the Christmas story: a call to embrace the marginalized and provide refuge to those in need. The story of Jesus’ birth challenges societies to extend compassion to strangers, reflecting the biblical mandate to “welcome the stranger” (Matthew 25:35).

It seems the MAGA movement was not paying attention in Sunday school and do not recall the injustices of his first term. True Christ followers will treat any immigrant as their neighbor, because it is literally commanded by God in the Bible:

“Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt.” – Exodus 22:21

“Cursed is anyone who withholds justice from the foreigner, the fatherless or the widow.” – Deuteronomy 21:19

“Do not forget to show hospitality to strangers.” – Hebrews 13:2

And dozens more. It is ultimately clear that Christianity requires us to accept the immigrant, as there are no illegals in the eyes of God.

Bridging the Divide: Lessons from the Nativity

The Christmas story serves as a powerful reminder that migration is not a new phenomenon but a recurring theme in human history. It calls for empathy and an acknowledgment of shared humanity. Mary, Joseph, and Jesus were migrants seeking safety and shelter, much like today’s refugees and asylum seekers. The political barriers and hostile attitudes they faced are still evident in contemporary debates about immigration.

To reconcile these lessons with current policies, we must prioritize compassion and inclusion over fear and exclusion. Immigration systems should focus on protecting the dignity and rights of migrants, providing them with opportunities to thrive rather than barriers that perpetuate suffering.

The birth of Jesus and the story of Christmas offer profound lessons about migration, resilience, and hope. By drawing parallels between the experiences of the Holy Family and modern migrants, we are reminded of the moral imperative to treat all people with dignity and compassion. We are all the descendants of immigrants.

The Nativity story challenges us to envision a more just and inclusive world—one that honors the fundamental humanity of all, regardless of borders or circumstances.

I challenge all of us, particularly evangelical christians, to reflect over the holidays on how we can make room in our country for a young pregnant couple doing their best to make their way through life.

We need to make room in the inn. Or we need to stop pretending this holiday has any true meaning.